Island Rentals | Royal Shell
REAL ESTATE SALES
RENT YOUR PROPERTY

logo ×

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Island Rentals

Sanibel Island & Captiva Island Rentals

These are two of Southwest Florida’s most loved beach destinations, but they offer different vacation experiences. Sanibel is typically better for shelling, biking, nature preserves, casual restaurants, and family-friendly beach trips. Captiva is usually better for sunsets, secluded beaches, boating, romantic getaways, and luxury island homes.

Guests who want a relaxed vacation with more everyday conveniences may prefer Sanibel. Guests who want a quieter, more tucked-away island escape may prefer Captiva. Royal Shell offers vacation rentals on both islands, including Gulf-front condos, beach homes, luxury rentals, dog-friendly stays, and monthly rental options.


Individual Property Coupon/Discount
Fall Promo 2026
NEW

Bonus Room

Flexible Cancellation Policy
Semi-Flexible Cancellation Policy
Standard Cancellation Policy

Luxury Collection

Boat Dock Available
Fishing Dock
Bikes Available

Gated Community
Community - Tennis Courts
Community Grilling Area
Private Barn
Saltwater Pool
EV Charger
Across the street from the beach

Roku TV
Apple TV
Streaming Only

Golf Cart Rental
Golf Optional

Event Property
Dog Friendly
Loading...

Showing of properties

Unable to find any listings.

Unable to find any listings.

Membership Dog OK Pool Boat Dock {[property.home_type]} {[property.home_type]} Guests Beds Bed Studio / Baths Bath / Baths
Enter Dates for Pricing
Insurance Included
Walk To Slopes
Hot Tub (Spa)
Lake View
Walk to Lake
Lakefront

Sanibel vs. Captiva

Which Island is Best for You?

Traveler Type Better Fit
Shelling and nature Sanibel
Sunsets and seclusion Captiva
Bike paths and wildlife Sanibel
Romantic island escape Captiva
Family beach condo Sanibel
Luxury beachfront home Captiva
Monthly winter stay Sanibel
Boating-focused trip Captiva (or Cape Coral for canal-front homes)